Before I rip into Matthew Vaughn’s X-Men: First Class, first a warning: everything beyond this point contains massive spoilers. If you plan to see X-Men I suggest you close your browser now before I completely ruin it for you.
Motivations
X-Men: First Class feels like what Lord of the Rings would have been if Miramax got its way and all three books were crammed into a single film. There is so much happening in this movie but not enough time for it to happen in, and character development suffers severely. Most of the character’s motivations are either unclear, or completely baffling.
Now if I was any kind of comic book nerd I could probably fill in the gaps myself without the movie spoon feeding me all necessary backstory, but I’m not. My love for comic book characters is mostly born from the cartoon shows I watched growing up in the 80’s and 90’s, so I’m willing to accept the argument can be made I hated First Class because of my general ignorance when it comes to X-Men canon. Fine.
My reply to that is it shouldn’t matter. A well crafted script should give us all the information we need. When Angel Salvadore (Zoe Kravitz), for example, turns her back on her fellow mutants to join the nefarious Sebastian Shaw (Kevin Bacon), her reasons should be clear to us. We can then either sympathize with her decision or hate her for it. If a character’s motivations are unclear then we don’t care and we end up with a very flat scene
Romance? Sure, why not?
At the end of the film Moira MacTaggert (Rose Byrne), a CIA agent working with the newly minted X-Men, kisses Professor Xavier (James McAvoy). I’m sure this has something to do with Moire being romantically linked with Professor X in the comics or some bullshit. I don’t know and I don’t care. All I was thinking when it happened was “where the fuck did that come?”
At no time was there even the slightest hint of sexual tension between McAvoy and Byrne. It was just, “well, okay they’re kissing now.” I don’t know what it is about Hollywood that thinks we’ll buy two people falling in love because they’ve been in the same room together at some point. X-Men: First Class does this constantly.
Raven (aka Mystique), played by Oscar nominee Jennifer Lawrence, falls in love with Beast (aka Hank McCoy) in the very first scene they appear together. In their just second scene together, Mystique creepily tries to kiss Hank (Nicholas Hoult) while he’s drawing her blood. I did not make that up. Even more ridiculous is Hank first wined and dined her with a little candle light diner before asking to take her blood for research. What a smoothie, right ladies?
I prefer Leonard McCoy
Speaking of Beast, his motivations lie in the “baffling” category. For those of you who don’t know the origins of Beast, Hank McCoy wasn’t always a big blue teddy bear. His mutation started out as simple case of over-sized feet. Ghastly looking, to be sure, but he seemed to have no trouble hiding them in a regular sized pair of shoes. In fact, the foot disguise worked so well that Hank’s CIA handlers hand no clue he was a even mutant! So why Hank spent the entire film whining about being different and wishing he could be normal, when clearly he was getting along just fine, is beyond me. Quite frankly it’s insulting to the other mutants who had fairy wings or devil tails.
As I understand it, in the comic book Hank McCoy not only had big feet, but big hands as well, which would have played way better with the “I’m sad I am different” sob story if he couldn’t hide it.
While I’m ragging on Beast, he’s a shitty scientist. Even I know that the first stage to a cure for any disorder doesn’t start with human testing. Before you try and cure your big feet, you should probably be sure it doesn’t do the opposite and give you big everything else. What’s worse is Hank tries to convince Mystique to have an injection party with him and his untested serum. Good job, there, super boyfriend.
The big crappy ending
The film hit its climax as with the USA and Russia on the brink of nuclear war. Through a series of mediocre fight scenes the X-Men defeat the big bad Bacon and halt a nuclear extinction. But for humans, the specter of dangerous mutants poses a grave threat and the order is given to annihilate Xavier and his merry mutant men. We might care about this sudden betrayal, except there is virtually no time spent in the film properly setting up the tension between humans and mutants.
This is something the first X-Men film did very well, opening with several scene featuring discrimination and injustice. X-Men: First Class, even though this is basically an origin story, spends almost no time on these themes. Most mutants seem to be doing just fine, in fact; decent jobs, big boats, castles. They aren’t hurting, that much is for certain. So when humans turn on the supposedly misunderstood mutants, it rings hollow.
That’s my two cents. I’m sure I’ll be hearing a lot about how wrong I am. So enjoy filling my comment box Jordan!
Filed under: Movies by
Gregg |
14 Comments »